Earlier today we discussed whether the Dallas Cowboys should offer DeMarco Murray a contract extension (Should the Dallas Cowboys Give DeMarco Murray a Contract Extension). It’s a debate that has been going on for some time and will likely continue for some time more. It’s no secret one of the top reasons his distractors dislike him is his propensity to injury.
That’s what we are asking this afternoon, Is DeMarco Murray injury-prone?
The short answer to that is YES. But that’s not really fair and certainly doesn’t tell the whole story. In 2013 DeMarco finished 10th in rushing yards despite missing 2 games. Let’s look at how the 9 players above him finished and what their injury history looks like…
- LeSean McCoy, arguably the best RB in the NFL not named Peterson, finished the season with 1607 rushing yards. He carried the ball 97 times more than Murray did and stayed healthy the entire season. But the three seasons before that McCoy missed at least one game every year.
- Matt Forte finished the season with 1339 rushing yards also playing the entire season. Three times in his previous five seasons Forte was able to play in every game, while the two other seasons he missed a total of 5 games.
- Jamaal Charles finished third in the NFL collecting 1287 yards. He missed one game in 2013. In his six year career he stayed healthy 2 times (one of those as the lead back).
- Alfred Morris finished the season with 1275 yards in only his second season. Despite the extremely heavy workload (335 attempts in 2012 and 276 in 2013) he has never missed a game.
- Adrian Peterson came back from a catastrophic knee injury to post 1266 yards in only 14 games. In his seven NFL seasons he played all 16 games three times. He missed time the four other seasons.
- Marshawn Lynch stayed healthy all year and picked up 1257 yards along the way. How many times did he play all 16 games in his previous seven seasons? Just once.
- Ryan Mathews is next on the list and after seeing he wasn’t on my fantasy football team for the first time, decided to breakout for 1255 yards in only 15 games. He technically played in all games but was only able to carry the ball 3 times in one of them. Before that he never even suited up for more than 14 games in a season.
- At #8 Eddie Lacy picked up 1178 yards in his rookie year. He played in all 16 games but only had one carry in week 2. With only one year of NFL experience it’s tough to draw any conclusion with Lacy, but he effectively handled nearly 18 carries per game in the regular season along with another 21 in the playoffs.
- Frank Gore rushed for 1128 yards in 2013. He played the entire season at the ripe old age of 30 too. The eight previous seasons with the 49ers Gore was able to play all 16 games in only 3 of them.
Finally we come to DeMarco Murray. DeMarco rushed for 1121 yards on only 217 carries (the least amount of carries of RBs in the top-10). But he missed 2 games in 2013 completing his trend of missing games in all 3 of his NFL seasons. Murray missed a little time in college, but not a disturbing amount by any means. Says Murray,
I really don’t pay too much attention to that. People will say I’m injury prone. I’ve gotten used to it. It’s not like I’ve been hurt every single year where I play four or five games, then miss one or two. I missed two games my junior year and three my freshman year. Five games in four years, not that bad. But like I said, I’m just trying to get better.
What Has This Taught Us?
This proves that DeMarco Murray may indeed be injury-prone but it also shows us virtually all top NFL RBs in the NFL are injury-prone too. It comes with the territory. An NFL RB is more susceptible to injury than your average player.
They are constantly in the line of fire whether they are carrying the ball themselves or pass-blocking a larger/stronger player.
This doesn’t completely absolve Murray either. Murray missed 2 games in 2014, 6 games in 2012, and 3 games in 2011. That’s a bit more fragile than you’d like to see from your lead back. While most top RBs in the NFL miss games, Murray seems to miss more than most.
The 2014 season should tell the tale of DeMarco Murray. Is he the guy who misses 2-3 games a year or the guy who misses closer to 6? There is a BIG difference between the two. Many Cowboys fans are demanding Murray stay healthy in 2014 (or else). That would be fantastic to see, but as history tells us, that’s not a very common thing for a lead back in today’s NFL.
Is DeMarco Murray injury-prone?
Sure…I guess…but so are most RBs. Murray may be a little more fragile than his peers but it’s tough to tell in only three seasons (2 of which he missed only 2-3 games). Earlier today we asked the question, Should the Dallas Cowboys Give DeMarco Murray an Extension? This article hopefully contributed to that conversation. Tomorrow morning we will continue the conversation and address the Salary Cap ramifications and the budget side of things.
Do you have questions or comments regarding Dallas area sports? Email Reid at [email protected]. You may be included in the next weekly mailbag. Follow Sport DFW on twitter @TheRealSportDFW Check out more of Reid’s articles here: http://sportdfw.com/author/reidhanson/