The Dallas Cowboys executive team comprises many individuals, but the visible three-headed monster includes Jerry Jones, Stephen Jones, and Will McClay.
McClay became the Vice President of Player Personnel for the Dallas Cowboys in 2018. He has been behind the men drafting and securing talent for America’s Team.
His resume has been very good in selecting first-round players, except for 2017.
Dallas Cowboys first-round draft picks over the last 10 years
— RJ Ochoa (@rjochoa) April 20, 2023
2022: Tyler Smith
2021: Micah Parsons
2020: CeeDee Lamb
2019: N/A
2018: Leighton Vander Esch
2017: Taco Charlton
2016: Ezekiel Elliott
2015: Byron Jones
2014: Zack Martin
2013: Travis Frederick
Round 1, Pick #28 – Taco Charlton
The 2017 NFL Draft got off to a very bumpy start. This is known as the Taco Charlton draft, and for good reason.
Dallas had the 28th overall selection that year, and they had a noticeable need at the defensive edge position. Two prominent names were on the board, and the Cowboys had a decision to make.
Unfortunately, they made the wrong one. Charlton and T.J. Watt were edge prospects, and even Watt’s family believed he would be the guy. There’s no secret there.
Spoke to #Steelers OLB @_TJWatt on playing vs #Cowboys. He shared on draft night 2017, after a pre-draft visit to Dallas, he took a call with Cowboys on clock. Family member put a Cowboys cap on Watt’s head, but call was from Mike Tomlin, not Dallas. Steelers took him at 30.
— Ed Werder (@WerderEdESPN) November 6, 2020
Taco was listed as 6’6″, 277lbs with a 4.92 in the 40-yard dash and a 1.7 10-yard split at that size. His NFL draft comparison was Chandler Jones. He definitely looked the part, there’s no denying that.
However, T.J. Watt should have clearly been the choice. If Dan Quinn had been the defensive coordinator in 2018, he might have been the choice.
Historically, Rod Marinelli went with the quicker outside linebacker type on the right-end position, similar to Watt, but that wasn’t the case in this draft.
It still needs to be confirmed what Marinelli’s preference was, but the Cowboys went with Charlton, and the returns were borderline pathetic, and that’s being really nice.
During Charlton’s tenure with Dallas, he tallied 41 combined tackles and 4 sacks in 27 games.
The starting job was open for the taking opposite Demarcus Lawrence. Randy Gregory dealt with his fair share of suspension issues, and Tyrone Crawford was more of the inside-outside defensive lineman.
The road could not have been any rosier for Taco, but he never could capitalize on it.
Coupled with the injuries, the fallout with the coaches, and attitude concerns, Dallas was stuck with only one recourse: waiving their first-round pick after only two years on the team.
They are not drafting Watt. Cutting bait on your 1st round choice. Talk about an opportunity cost down the toilet.
There is only one grade to give here.